What Do Africans Really Think About the Death Penalty?

Public Opinion, Culture, and the Future of Capital Punishment on the Continent

As capital punishment continues to spark legal reform and constitutional debate across Africa, an often overlooked question remains at the heart of the matter: What do ordinary Africans really think about the death penalty?

While legislative bodies and human rights organizations push for abolition, public sentiment appears far more complex sometimes contradictory. In communities affected by violent crime, many citizens continue to see the death penalty as a necessary deterrent. In others, where trust in the justice system is low, capital punishment is viewed with growing skepticism.

In this article, Legal Africa Magazine explores public attitudes across the continent drawing from polling data, cultural context, and the growing influence of civil society on reshaping the African justice conversation.

A Continent Divided: Regional Patterns in Public Opinion

Surveys conducted by Afrobarometer, one of Africa’s most respected polling organizations, show that support for the death penalty remains high in several African countries, particularly where crime and insecurity dominate public discourse.

• In Nigeria, nearly 70% of respondents in a 2022 poll expressed support for the death penalty, citing rising levels of terrorism, kidnapping, and ritual killings.

• In South Africa, although the death penalty was abolished in 1995, public support continues to linger, especially during periods of high-profile crime waves.

• In Ghana and Kenya, support remains strong in rural and peri-urban areas, with many citizens associating capital punishment with justice and closure.

In contrast, countries like Rwanda, Sierra Leone, and Zambia all of which have moved to abolish the death penalty in recent years have seen a steady decline in public appetite for executions, especially among younger populations and in urban centers.

Justice or Revenge? Cultural and Religious Perspectives

Public support for the death penalty in Africa is often rooted in deeply held cultural and religious beliefs.

• In many African communities, justice is seen as retributive, not just restorative. The idea of “an eye for an eye” resonates strongly in traditional systems of justice where community healing is tied to punitive outcomes.

• In Islamic regions such as parts of northern Nigeria and Sudan, Sharia-based legal systems still endorse capital punishment for certain offenses, and local populations are more likely to support its enforcement.

• Meanwhile, Christian denominations across Africa have taken mixed positions. The Catholic Church, especially under Pope Francis, has called for global abolition, and local bishops in countries like Malawi, Rwanda, and South Africa have echoed that call.

Yet, there is growing generational divergence. Younger Africans especially those with higher education and internet access tend to favor life imprisonment over execution, citing concerns over wrongful convictions and human rights.

The Trust Factor: Legal Systems Under Scrutiny

A key factor shaping public opinion on capital punishment is trust or the lack of it in the legal system.

In many countries, public institutions are plagued by corruption, prolonged trials, and systemic bias, especially against the poor, uneducated, or politically unconnected. As a result, some citizens support the death penalty in principle, but fear its misuse in practice.

A 2021 Afrobarometer report found that less than 40% of Africans trust their courts to deliver fair and impartial justice. In such a context, the irreversible nature of execution raises serious concerns.

Cases like Ken Saro-Wiwa in Nigeria, or Benedicto Kiwanuka’s political execution in Uganda, have become historical cautionary tales reminders that when the rule of law is weak, the death penalty can become a weapon rather than a safeguard.

The Media Effect: High-Profile Crimes and Emotional Swings

Another powerful influence on public sentiment is the media’s framing of crime and punishment. When high-profile murders, rapes, or armed robberies dominate headlines, public demand for swift justice including execution spikes dramatically.

In Ghana, the gruesome murder of a 10-year-old boy in a suspected ritual killing case in 2021 reignited calls for the death penalty to be enforced more decisively. Similar patterns have been observed in South Africa and Kenya, where media sensationalism fuels populist justice narratives.

However, in-depth reporting on wrongful convictions and prison conditions has also helped shift opinions, especially when victims of state injustice share their stories. NGOs and legal reformers are increasingly using documentaries, podcasts, and social media to highlight flaws in capital punishment systems and build momentum for change.

A Shifting Landscape: Civil Society and the Road to Reform

Despite widespread support for the death penalty in some regions, civil society organizations have made significant gains in reshaping public opinion particularly by connecting capital punishment to broader human rights issues.

Groups like Death Penalty Project Africa, Legal Resource Foundation (Zimbabwe), and PRI Africa have led public education campaigns, supported strategic litigation, and provided legal aid to those facing execution.

In Zambia, a coalition of lawyers, churches, and youth groups played a critical role in influencing government and parliament to abolish the death penalty in 2023. In Sierra Leone, the 2021 abolition followed months of advocacy that directly engaged communities on the risks of wrongful execution.

 Public Will, Political Courage, and the Future of the Death Penalty in Africa

Public opinion in Africa on capital punishment is neither monolithic nor static. It is shaped by lived realities of crime, justice, and broken systems as well as by evolving values, global trends, and civic education.

For policymakers and reformers, understanding this complexity is essential. Capital punishment will not end in Africa simply because international actors demand it; it will end when Africans themselves believe there is a better path to justice.

That change is already visible. But to sustain it, Africa’s legal institutions must rebuild public trust, address the root causes of crime, and ensure that justice is not just swift but fair.

📌 Legal Africa Magazine continues to track justice trends across the continent. Got insight, opinion, or data to share? Email us at info@legalafrica.org.

READ RELATED ARTICLES HERE: Iconic Capital Punishment Cases That Shaped Africa’s Legal and Political History